| # | Name | POS | B | T | School | GRAD | Hometown |
| 23 | John Brennan | P/3B | R | R | Suffern H | 2011 | Suffern |
| 3 | Nick Burns | 2B | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 14 | Sean Fenster | OF | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 7 | Alex Fishberg | C | R | R | Suffern MS | 2012 | Suffern |
| 13 | Richie Glover | C | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 6 | Billy Goldman | OF/P | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 15 | Mike Gorton | 3B/P | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 2 | Dylan Hayward | OF | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 5 | David Lopez | 1B | L | L | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 4 | Lucas Lopez | IF | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 9 | Dan Ortiz | 1B | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 8 | Aaron Schwartz | C | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 11 | Danny Small | 2B | R | R | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |
| 10 | Jake Traub | P/1B | L | L | Suffern HS | 2011 | Suffern |